Review · NEW YORK CITY
Speakeasy Drinks and Prohibition History Tour NYC
New York’s Prohibition story comes alive best after dark, when a plain doorway, a crowded theater block, or a polished cocktail bar can all carry a little mystery. This three-hour walk links three Midtown drinking spots with tales of bootleggers, old nightlife, and the personalities who shaped the city’s Gilded Age.
I like the mix of guided storytelling and real stops, rather than a lecture followed by a walk home. I also like the small group, capped at 18, and guides such as Ryan, Ariel, Walter, Katherine, and Julian, who bring humor and local detail to the evening. The main catch is simple: drinks cost extra, and not every venue feels like a true speakeasy.
Key points to know before booking

- Three very different bars: Expect a mix of historic, modern, theatrical, and cocktail-focused venues rather than three perfectly preserved Prohibition hideouts.
- Stories make the tour: Ryan, Ariel, Walter, Katherine, Julian, Emma, and other local guides have been praised for humor and strong storytelling.
- Drinks are not included: Cocktails often run about $20 each, so three drinks can add roughly $60 per person before any extra charges.
- Midtown route: You’ll walk around Times Square, the Broadway theater district, and the area just south of Central Park.
- Upscale casual dress: Sportswear and ripped clothing are not allowed, and you need to be at least 21 with valid photo identification.
- Good for a social evening: The group limit is 18, and solo visitors can meet people while moving between bars.
Starting on Eighth Avenue in Midtown

The tour begins at 825 8th Avenue, a practical Midtown meeting point close to Times Square and public transportation. That location matters because you are already in the middle of New York’s theater and nightlife zone, not spending the first half-hour getting out to a distant neighborhood.
From there, your guide sets the tone. The best part of this experience is not simply getting through a door. It is learning how New York nightlife changed during Prohibition, when legal restrictions pushed drinking into private clubs, back rooms, and places that needed a little secrecy.
You can expect the guide to explain the period as you walk, linking the city’s Gilded Age wealth, theater culture, organized crime, and nightlife. The guides most often singled out for their presentation include Ryan and Ariel, along with Walter, Katherine, and Julian. Ryan in particular is praised for keeping the stories moving and tying each bar to the larger theme.
The walk itself is moderate rather than strenuous. It lasts around three hours, but much of that time is spent inside the venues. You should still wear comfortable shoes, since you will move through Midtown streets and stand at some points.
More Speakeasy and Hidden Bar Tours in the USA
- NYC: Speakeasy Drinks and Prohibition History Tour
★ 4.7 · 474 reviews - Guided Speakeasy Walking Tour of New York City
★ 4.5 · 336 reviews - The Speakeasy Adventure: A Tipsy Trip Through History
★ 5.0 · 220 reviews
Times Square, Broadway, and the city after dark
Times Square is not subtle. Its lights, crowds, theaters, and constant movement are a sharp contrast to the quiet secrecy associated with old speakeasies. That contrast is part of the fun.
The route passes through the Broadway theater district and the area just north of Times Square and south of Central Park. These streets help explain why Midtown became such a powerful nightlife center. The district has long mixed theaters, hotels, restaurants, clubs, and late-night traffic, so the walk gives you more city context than a bar crawl that begins and ends indoors.
I like this part of the tour because you get a sense of place between drinks. You are not simply being driven from one venue to another. The streets connect the story, even if the route is not a major sightseeing walk in the usual sense.
The downside is noise. Times Square and Broadway can be loud, and some bars use strong music. One person found that the sound at the first and last stops made it hard to hear some of the historical talk. If you care most about the history, stay close to the guide and ask questions while walking between venues, when it is easier to listen.
The first stop gives you the strongest speakeasy feel

The opening venue is generally the stop most likely to match the classic speakeasy idea: an unobvious entrance, a more concealed setting, and creative cocktails. One account described the first bar as having the password-and-hidden-door feel many people expect when they book this tour.
That first stop is a strong reason to choose the experience. You get the thrill of finding a place you might not notice on your own, and the guide can explain how secrecy worked in the Prohibition era. The setting also gives the stories a natural backdrop instead of making them feel like a standard walking lecture.
Your drink is your own purchase. A cocktail may cost around $20, which is normal for a themed Midtown bar but not a small add-on when repeated three times. You are not required to order three full cocktails simply because there are three stops, but the format is built around sampling the venues.
The guide may help with recommendations, and several guides have been praised for knowing the drinks as well as the local stories. Still, the tour price covers admission and preferred entry, not your food or alcohol.
The second venue may feel more like a cocktail bar

The middle stop is where expectations need adjusting. Depending on the night and the current venue lineup, you may enter a restaurant or clearly marked cocktail venue rather than a hidden room.
Lillie’s has been identified as one such stop. It can be enjoyable, but it may not feel secret or difficult to find. That does not make it a bad bar. It simply means the word speakeasy is being used broadly, covering places with period themes, old New York connections, or a dramatic atmosphere as well as truly concealed clubs.
This is the main gap between the sales pitch and the likely experience. If you want three historic bars with secret passwords and untouched Prohibition character, you could feel let down. If you want three different Midtown venues connected by stories, the variety works better.
The second stop also gives you a change of pace. After the dark, hidden feel of the first venue, a more open restaurant or polished bar shows how the speakeasy idea has been turned into modern entertainment. That comparison can be useful, as long as you know you are not visiting a museum piece.
More Speakeasy and Hidden Bar Tours in New York City:
- NYC: Night Out Prohibition History Bar and Speakeasy Tour
★ 4.6 · 128 reviews - Secret bars and Speakeasy NY experience
★ 4.4 · 50 reviews - Hidden Bar and Speakeasy Night Tour NYC
★ 5.0 · 48 reviews - New York Greenwich Village Speakeasy and Ghost Tour (with pizza!)
★ 5.0 · 29 reviews
The final stop leans toward theater and atmosphere

The third venue brings another shift in mood. It may have an Art Deco look, a Broadway theme, live music, or another strong design concept. One version of the route included a newer bar with a polished, theatrical feel. Another stop has been described as a lively music venue.
This is often the most social part of the night. You can expect more energy, and possibly more difficulty hearing the guide if the music is loud. The setting may be memorable, but it is not always a convincing Prohibition hideaway.
The reviews of the final drinks are mixed. Some people found them strong and enjoyable, while one person disliked the cocktails but liked the food. That is a useful warning for anyone booking mainly for drinks: the venues are selected for atmosphere and variety, not because every cocktail will suit every palate.
The Woo Woo has also been mentioned as a favorite stop, with a fun themed setting. Since the exact lineup can change, I would treat named venues as examples rather than guarantees. The basic promise is three different bars, not three fixed addresses.
What the guide adds to the night
A good guide is the difference between a bar crawl and a proper city experience. Here, the strongest part of the evening is the human delivery.
Ryan is often praised for wit, timing, and detailed stories. Ariel is described as funny and informative, while Walter is credited with keeping the evening entertaining and full of facts. Katherine has been praised for combining local perspective with a relaxed style, and Julian for making the history easy to follow.
The guides also seem to adjust to the group. One account describes a guide changing plans to suit weather and conditions. That matters in New York, where rain, traffic, street closures, and crowded sidewalks can alter the rhythm of an evening.
The quality may vary by guide and group size. One person found the historical material too light, especially when music drowned out the talk. I would not book this expecting a college-level Prohibition seminar. Think of it as accessible city history delivered in short bursts between drinks.
The real cost is more than $38

The advertised price is $38 per person, which is reasonable for a three-hour guided walk with admission and preferred entry at three venues. It is a good base price if you mainly want the guide and the access.
Your full evening budget needs to be higher. Drinks and food are not included, and cocktails can cost about $20 at each stop. Three drinks could add about $60 per person, making the night roughly $98 before any separate gratuity for the tour and before food.
Some accounts indicate that taxes and tips for drinks were collected through the guide or included in the amount charged at the venue. Since the handling can be unclear, ask at the start how each bill works. The tour’s own gratuity is not included.
For two people, three cocktails each can push the total well above $150. That is not unusual for Midtown nightlife, but it changes the value calculation. You are paying for guided access, stories, and a planned evening, not for cheap drinks.
I think the tour offers fair value if you would otherwise spend the night choosing bars on your own. It offers weaker value if you only want hidden entrances and historic interiors, or if you plan to order several expensive cocktails at every stop.
Who will enjoy this most

I would recommend this tour to first-time New York visitors who want a social night in Midtown without planning every detail. It also suits solo visitors, since the group format gives you company and a simple way to meet people.
Couples and small groups can enjoy it as a birthday outing or a different kind of night in the city. The guide handles the route, the history, and entry, so you can focus on the company and the atmosphere.
It is less suitable for anyone under 21, visitors who do not want to drink, or people seeking a serious architectural and historical tour. The activity has a minimum age of 21, and you need valid photo identification. Non-US citizens are told to bring a passport.
The dress code is also worth taking seriously. Upscale casual clothing is required, with no sportswear or ripped clothing. You do not need formal evening wear, but sneakers with athletic clothing or very casual outfits could cause trouble at the door.
Timing, group size, and practical planning
The tour lasts about three hours and offers several start times, which makes it easy to fit around dinner, a Broadway show, or another Midtown plan. Do not schedule it so tightly that you must rush away at the end. The final stop ends around Times Square, in Manhattan, so you remain well placed for a late meal or more nightlife.
The group limit is 18 people. That is small enough for a guide to speak with you directly, though the experience can still feel lively at the venues. Smaller groups may get more conversation and easier access to the guide.
The route is near public transportation, but the supplied details do not promise a specific accessibility setup. Since the activity involves walking between venues and requires a moderate fitness level, contact the provider before booking if stairs, standing, or street walking could be a concern.
Free cancellation is available if you cancel at least 24 hours before the start time. Changes or cancellations inside that window are not accepted for a refund. The experience also needs a minimum number of participants, so if the provider cancels for that reason, you can choose another date or receive a full refund.
Should you book the Speakeasy Drinks and Prohibition History Tour?
Book it if you want a guided night out with three contrasting Midtown bars, good stories, and a social group. The best guides add real value, and the first venue is likely to deliver the hidden-door feeling you have in mind.
Do not book it expecting three untouched Prohibition-era speakeasies. At least one or two stops may feel like modern themed bars, restaurants, or cocktail lounges. You should also budget for roughly $20 per drink and accept that music may make some storytelling harder to hear.
My call: this is a strong choice for a first New York visit, a birthday evening, or a solo night when you want company. For serious Prohibition fans, I would book only after confirming the current venues and asking how much historical talk happens inside each bar.
FAQ
How long does the tour last?
The experience lasts approximately three hours.
Where does the tour begin?
It begins at 825 8th Avenue, New York, NY 10019.
Where does the tour end?
It ends in Times Square, Manhattan, New York, NY 10036.
How many venues do you visit?
You visit three bars or speakeasy-style venues, ranging from historic locations to modern cocktail spots.
Are drinks and food included?
No. Drinks and food are available for purchase at the venues and are not included in the tour price.
What is the minimum age?
The minimum age is 21. You must bring valid photo identification. Non-US citizens are instructed to bring a passport.
What should you wear?
The dress code is upscale casual. Sportswear and ripped clothing are not permitted.
Can you cancel for a full refund?
Yes. You can cancel at least 24 hours before the experience begins for a full refund. Cancellations or changes made less than 24 hours before the start time are not refunded.
Bar walks with the history told around New York City
- The NYC Speakeasy Adventure: A Tipsy Trip Through History
★ 5.0 · 6 reviews - Private Speakeasy Adventure A Tipsy Trip through History
★ 5.0 · 5 reviews - New Orleans Cocktail and Food History Tour
★ 5.0 · 819 reviews - New Orleans Cocktail History Walking Tour in the French Quarter
★ 5.0 · 604 reviews
Last orders added around New York City
- Private Speakeasy Adventure A Tipsy Trip through History★ 5.0 · 5 reviews
- New York Greenwich Village Speakeasy and Ghost Tour (with pizza!)★ 5.0 · 29 reviews
- Bar, Lounge and Rooftop Tour NYC★ 4.5 · 88 reviews
- 2-Hour Spanish Nightlife Guided Walking Tour of Greenwich Village★ 5.0 · 11 reviews
- New Years Eve Speakeasy Drinks and Ball Drop Tour NYC★ 4.0 · 3 reviews
- New York City Sunset Cocktail Cruise on Small Yacht★ 5.0 · 71 reviews
- NYC Nightlife Tour with a Local: Private & Personalized★ 5.0 · 4 reviews
- Rooftop, Bar & Speakeasy Soirée★ 5.0 · 10 reviews
New York City Bar Crawls: the next round

The Speakeasy Adventure: A Tipsy Trip Through History
Read our review →
Night Out Prohibition History Bar and Speakeasy Tour
Read our review →
Guided Walking Tour of Greenwich Village Nightlife
Read our review →This night out also appears in





